I committed to making a big leap forward in inequalities this year. They’ve always been low priority in my curriculum, nothing more than a subset of equations, even though as a programmer, I can come up with fifteen real-life examples of working with them—much more than I can for linear equations. But once I kicked off linear equations with modeling, I could see some obvious introduction points that would help them fall into place. I committed the time to design some new lessons and build some new handouts. And I completely forgot to take pictures of the boardwork, dammit.

Back to tacos and burritos, but this time I took away the “spend all the money” constraint. Stan could either make the purchase or he couldn’t. I gave them some starting combinations to test, and then they came up with their own.

By this time, they are old hands at modeling and easily came up with more true and false pairs. I then graphed all the points on the board, using blue for “True” values, and red for “False”.

“See that space between the TRUE and FALSE values? You can see pretty clearly there’s a line separating them, like this:

“Take a second. What might that line be?” I’m pleased to see several hands shoot up, but I pick on Karl, slinking away from my glance up front. “Karl?”

“I don’t know.”

“What if it wasn’t an inequality?”

“Well, then it’d be 3x + 5y = 60….oh. It’s the same line?”

“Yeah,” chimed in three other students.

“Yes, exactly. We are now working with linear *inequalities*, not linear *equations*. Solutions aren’t defined by a single point, but by entire regions. The line is the same in both equations and inequalities, but in an inequality, the line acts as a border between the TRUE and FALSE values. Everything on one side of the line is TRUE, and everything on the other is FALSE.”

From there, I give them one of the new handouts:

I’m really pleased with this one, as a first pass. The students plot the TRUE and FALSE values in different colors. Then they determine which of the linear inequality borders will correctly separate the regions. In one exercise, they become more familiar with solution regions, while also improving their ability to visualize lines from an equation (especially, god help me, positive and negative slopes).

Next, I give them a notes handout I’ve modified over the years.

as well as board notes a few days later:

I made two HUGE changes this year from previous years, changes I suspect most math teachers will recognize.

First, I abandoned “above and below the line” test for the solution region. This seems so obvious to math teachers, but it’s really only meaningful to about half the students. Worse, the test only works with slope intercept form, and has no validity in standard form. The purple math link above tells the student to solve the equation for y—yeah, because solving inequalities is such a breeze, particularly with negatives. It’s a kluge. I didn’t even mention that test.

Instead, I had them use (0,0) for a test value and had them test the value for all forms. MUCH better. No “hey, remember the first way I taught you? Above and below the line? It doesn’t work in standard form, so here’s another way!” Testing values always works.

(Liam in the comments pointed out that the test value can’t be *on* the border, and I do cover this. I don’t put it in my notes, though. I used to, but the kids would get very confused at the caveat. So now I wait until they are confident of the (0,0) point test and then introduce an example in which the point is on the border equation. I’m discovering that it sometimes takes me a couple years through before I figure out the best way to create fully complete notes.)

Second, I had them write “true” or “false” by the test point, and then shade the same or opposite side of the line. This gave them a visual and kinesthetic step in the process: One, test the inequality with (0,0). Two, write “true” or “false”. Three, shade the correct side of the line.

I’m sure in later years I’ll further hone this, but this was the first time I felt good about my linear inequalities unit. From there, systems of inequalities was an obvious step:

I did a day of modeling systems, but no, I didn’t go onto linear programming.. Instead, I moved onto practicing graphing without the models, and they did great.

I used one of my favorite worksheets as a quiz. The average grade was a B+. Check out this sample—see the “true” markings? By golly, they listened.

I was so emboldened by my success I went onto absolute values, which I usually only cover for tests. They did all right with that, too.

I’m grading the second unit test, covering linear equations, inequalities, and absolute values. So far, it’s looking very good.

March 11th, 2013 at 6:12 pm

Careful with only using (0,0) as a test point. It works most of the time, except when the associated line passes through the origin, and then all they find out is that the point is on the line. I usually say, “We pick any point not on the line, (0,0) is my favorite but I can’t pick it if it’s on the line…”

March 11th, 2013 at 6:22 pm

Yep. I was writing this late at night and neglected to mention a few things. I’ll go add them now.

March 13th, 2013 at 2:51 pm

Dear Educationrealist,

I have nobody else to pose this question to, so here it is.

What is the proper terminology, which is

used in American Math education system,

for the planar geometry problems of drawing some object

with the use of a compass and the ruler only ?

It is doing these problems, that I learned the sacramental phrase:

“…t hus reducing the problem to the one solved previously”.

With fascination of your work,

Your truly, Florida resident.

March 13th, 2013 at 3:00 pm

That’s called “construction”.

May 6th, 2013 at 1:27 am

[…] Modeling Linear Inequalities Teaching Trig […]

June 15th, 2013 at 7:35 am

If you get a chance, would you please let me know how you created the handouts. I am interested in the graphs on the second set of handouts.

June 15th, 2013 at 2:17 pm

Are you talking about the Ohio Jones graph? That was created by Dan Green, and I include the link. If you’re talking about the empty graphs, I honestly don’t know where I got it anymore. I probably copied it off of a file back when I was a student teacher and used it ever since. I’m happy to send you a copy. If you’re talking about the actual lines that are built in word, I don’t do that anymore—too inaccurate. I use Holt’s online graphing calculator or Desmos and then capture the image.

So just let me know which one you are interested in.

December 7th, 2013 at 8:27 pm

[…] difficulty and breadth of coverage I can deliver. Not a lot. But some. For example, I now teach the modeling of inequalities, modeling of absolute values, and function operations, in addition to modeling linear equations, […]

April 1st, 2014 at 12:00 am

[…] a lot with feasibility regions and of course, systems of inequalities. I describe my approach for Algebra II, but I step it up a bunch of paces for A2/Trig. I expect them to be able to graph lines and […]

June 16th, 2014 at 12:06 am

I was wondering if you would be willing to share copies of the handouts you used? We are initiating our math 1 class this fall and I am impressed with the incites you have shared on teaching both linear equations and inequalities.

June 16th, 2014 at 12:40 am

Sure. Check them closely for minor errors; I’m pretty famous for forgetting things that math people find important. Email me and I’ll send them.

August 31st, 2014 at 10:38 pm

[…] other times I do a brief classroom discussion/lecture first (modeling linear equations and inequalities). Sometimes I have an all practice day or two—I’ve covered a lot of material, now […]

March 30th, 2015 at 1:24 am

[…] Once I got out of the algebra I ghetto (which really does warp your brain if that’s all you do), I accepted that a lot of the concepts I originally thought boring or unimportant show up later. So it’s worth my time to come up with the same third way activities and lessons for things like functions or absolute value or inverses that I do for binomial multiplication and modeling linear equations and inequalities. […]

December 28th, 2015 at 4:35 am

[…] sure of. Homer also went through the effort of testing regions as “true”, as I teach them, while Max just visualized them (and probably would have been made a mistake had I been more […]

August 3rd, 2016 at 3:24 pm

[…] I challenged myself in that moment to come up with something different. How could I introduce linear inequalities in such a way that would build on the linear equations, while showing their differences? I still […]

November 19th, 2016 at 8:57 pm

[…] snickers in my algebra 2 class as I explained how to test regions for systems of inequalities , which took me a while to figure […]